adccommunitymod (AutomationDirect) asked a question.

Boat Lift Simple Program

Created Date: October 19,2018

Created By: luvs2div

**** This post has been imported from our legacy forum. Information in this post may be outdated and links contained in the post may no longer work.****

Not totally new to PLC ladder logic BUT... its been 30 years.... Bought a Click C0-00DR-D and a 4 channel output wireless remote control to raise/lower a boat lift. Air blower and solenoid valve energize to blow air into 3 tanks/floats under the boat. Energize the solenoid valve only, will lower the boat. Just dumps the air out. There are 4 positions for the lift: All the way up with boat on (heavy). All the way up with no boat on (No weight). Half way up with boat (easier to get on/off the boat). All the way down (submerged). The different up positions will just vary the time the blower and solenoid valve are energized. Down is just opening solenoid valve and the air just escapes the floats for a given period of time. 3 output devices: 120VAC solenoid Valve (.7 amps). 120VAC blower motor (.5 amps) 24VDC Strobe (flashes whenever the solenoid is energized). Of course 5 amp 24VDC power supply, NEMA 4X enclosure, Click C0-00DR-D, and a 4 channel remote control. Is this even possible with only 6 outputs on the PLC? Since this is 4 separate 24vdc inputs from the remote, is it possible to reference the same solenoid output for each timing circuit? Any and all opinions/help would be appreciated. Cheers.


  • adccommunitymod (AutomationDirect)

    Created Date: October 19,2018

    Created by: luvs2div

    Not totally new to PLC ladder logic BUT... its been 30 years....

    Bought a Click C0-00DR-D and a 4 channel output wireless remote control to raise/lower a boat lift. Air blower and solenoid valve energize to blow air into 3 tanks/floats under the boat. Energize the solenoid valve only, will lower the boat. Just dumps the air out.

    There are 4 positions for the lift:

    All the way up with boat on (heavy).

    All the way up with no boat on (No weight).

    Half way up with boat (easier to get on/off the boat).

    All the way down (submerged).

    The different up positions will just vary the time the blower and solenoid valve are energized.

    Down is just opening solenoid valve and the air just escapes the floats for a given period of time.

    3 output devices:

    120VAC solenoid Valve (.7 amps).

    120VAC blower motor (.5 amps)

    24VDC Strobe (flashes whenever the solenoid is energized).

    Of course 5 amp 24VDC power supply, NEMA 4X enclosure, Click C0-00DR-D, and a 4 channel remote control.

    Is this even possible with only 6 outputs on the PLC? Since this is 4 separate 24vdc inputs from the remote, is it possible to reference the same solenoid output for each timing circuit?

    Any and all opinions/help would be appreciated. Cheers.

    Expand Post
  • adccommunitymod (AutomationDirect)

    Created Date: October 19,2018

    Created by: RogerR

    You can use logic on your outputs for any number of inputs, internal logical Cbits, or timer bits.

    It looks like only three outputs will be required, with six available.

    The 120vac loads will have to be on one common bundle and the 24vdc load will have to be on the other.

    C3 to Y1-Y4

    C4 to Y5-Y6

    Expand Post
  • adccommunitymod (AutomationDirect)

    Created Date: October 19,2018

    Created by: quaizywabbit

    any limit switches to know the positions? one for all the way up, one for all the way down. etc.. each would use an input, so with your wireless as inputs, your commanding them to move to a position. the limits would tell the plc you got there.

  • adccommunitymod (AutomationDirect)

    Created Date: October 22,2018

    Created by: luvs2div

    No prox or limit switches needed. Just timing circuit to blow air into the tanks. cant overfill them so I don't think switches are needed... yet...

  • adccommunitymod (AutomationDirect)

    Created Date: October 22,2018

    Created by: luvs2div

    If any experienced programmers are willing to assist me on this, it wont make me feel bad. A little worthless maybe, but not bad. :-)

  • adccommunitymod (AutomationDirect)

    Created Date: October 22,2018

    Created by: bcarlton

    A few questions:

    If the lift is partway suspended and you wish to go up further would the blower motor need to turn on first then after a delay to allow for air pressure build up open the solenoid? Otherwise the lift may drop a bit while the blower is coming up to pressure.

    The top two 'positions ' differ only in the presence of the boat. Since there is no feedback aren't they basically the same thing. The PLC won't 'know ' which of the two positions it's at. I assume the floats are filled with air in either case.

    Will you be going to the half way up position from either all the way up or all the way down? What if it's already at the half way up position when the command is given?

    Wouldn't this be simpler to just have two buttons, one energizing both the blower and the solenoid and the other just energizing the solenoid? Or will the lift be out of view of the operator (unsafe?).

    Expand Post
  • adccommunitymod (AutomationDirect)

    Created Date: October 22,2018

    Created by: luvs2div

    Bernie,

    The blower and valve could open at the same time. Pressure doesn't drop fast enough to lower the boat at all in a very short time frame. Takes 2 seconds to come up to pressure. Also, once the tanks are fully pressurized, they just blow bubbles out of the holes in the bottom of the tanks. Each tank has a 4 " hole on the very bottom that stays open. Once pressure is maxed out it the tank, the overpressure just blows out the bottom. That's a good indication the tanks are full.

    The two "positions " are one with the boat and one without. Since one position isn't lifting 4000 pounds of boat, it shouldn't take that much air just to float the tanks alone. With the boat it takes about 4 minutes to raise all the way. With no boat, about 45 seconds. The lift has to always be up when the boat is not on it. Resort rules.

    It will be going to the hallway up position from the full up position.

    Yes, probably easier but not near as cool... lol. The lift will always be in sight of the operator.

    Expand Post
  • adccommunitymod (AutomationDirect)

    Created Date: October 22,2018

    Created by: bcarlton

    Then you have 10 possible moves/timings:

    1. Go all the way down from full up - with boat

    2. Go all the way down from full up - empty

    3. Go all the way down from half way up - with boat

    4. Go all the way down from half way up - empty

    5. Go all the way up from full down - with boat

    6. Go all the way up from full down - empty

    7. Go all the way up from half way up - with boat

    8. Go all the way up from half way up - empty

    9. Go to halfway from full up - with boat

    10. Go to halfway from full up - empty

    1 - 4 can be combined with the timing being the longest needed

    5 - 8 can be combined in the same way

    This leaves 4 moves/timings

    1. Go all the way down

    2. Go all the way up

    3. Go half way down from full up - with boat

    4. Go half way down from full up - empty

    But note - without feedback the system cannot tell if it was full up to properly execute 3, 4

    If the lift was all the way up wouldn't slow dissolving of air into the water through the bottom holes cause the lift to drift downward over time?

    Sorry for all this but these are the type of questions I asked of our machine designers while I was still working.

    Expand Post
  • adccommunitymod (AutomationDirect)

    Created Date: October 23,2018

    Created by: luvs2div

    So both number 4's, 8, and 10, should never happen. Halfway without the boat doesn't need to happen.

    Feedback could be an option later but this isn't a very precise setup. But I may look at that this weekend.....

    The air may lose a little "lift " over time but the boat has been on the lift for up to 2 months straight with no visual "drop " of the lift.

    Expand Post
  • adccommunitymod (AutomationDirect)

    Created Date: October 23,2018

    Created by: Alexandru

    There are so many ways to do it right, that chances are you’ll end up doing it wrong. Yes, 4 outputs is enough. But you need inputs. Forget timing the blower.

    General considerations

    whatever automation you build up, the first concern is wether is safe in operation.

    in your case, safe means:

    1. No electrical hazards

    2. No mechanical hazards

    3. No hazards due to pneumatics

    4. No hazards resulting from automation and control.

    this is the start up of your project. I wouldn’t just hands-it-on and learn on the job. Now let’s eliminate the hazards:

    1. No electrical hazards: make sure the electrical wiring and connections are certified. If you do them yourself and choose to consider it safe, then you need to affix a paper or a sticker to the control panel stating the contact info of the builder as well as the extent of electrical work outside the panel that falls under the liability of the builder. This seems as a witch-hunt for the case things go wrong, but is meant to insure confidence and save lives.

    2. No mechanical hazards: again, a mechanical builder needs to have its contact info stamped on a visible place on the structure. Not submerged. If the entire work was commissioned by one manufacturer, then the control panel stamp is enough.

    3. No hazards due to pneumatics: any form of ebpnergy accumulated in machinery needs to be checked for inadvertent release. If a pressurized line blows while the human is underneath the equipment, will the humans be caught? How about with people aboard? If in your case an air tank fails, what are the possible repercussions? Please figure or at least project an estimate to this failure, which you could further refine during commissioning.

    4. No hazards resulting from automation and control. Finally. Only at this moment you should start to develop the automation

    any piece of machinery has at least two control modes

    fully automatic

    manual

    some equipments have a maintenance mode, which is similar to manual but with extra safeties bypassed. We won’t deal with that because is inherently unsafe even for certified troubleshooting personnel. Hence, illegal.

    the main difference between fully automatic and manual is that in automatic the machinery can execute a certain cycle ( starting from one predefined position and ending in another predifened stop position.

    Start and stop position can be one in many, they can be chained together ( when stop coincides with a start) resulting in various sequences of operation, including automatic restart when last stop coincides with a possible start.

    another difference: usually, in automatic the eauipment runs at a predefined seeped, higher that what it does in manual.

    one last difference which applies to your project: in manual, the machine could stop and restart from positions which are not predefined. This is usually due to low speed.

    how all this relates to your project:

    1. You don’t have different speeds. Therefore your automatic mode can be skipped altogether. This adds extra safety since the human operator oversees the process.

    2. Although the untermediate height can be decided by how long the operator chooses to lift, the down and the up require safety switches. Personally, I would be looking to implement redundant safety. I’ll come to that later. But for now, you need ate least two limit switches, better three switches to have the middle height set as well. That is three plc inputs.

    3. Implementing the lifting via air tanks for the u-boat you’re building defeats the purpose of having redundant safety in case pneumatics blows. What happens with boat? Will just fall? Will it tilt or list dangerously? Assuming the the equipment will work is not safe.

    4. So you blow air for a minute. Boat lifts half way. Then another minute and boat is airborne. Then release the air and boat sinks . Cool!

    Expand Post
10 of 13